Here's the 19 songs from 2017 that appeared in the 2025 countdown:
COLORS

DREAMS

BECK

COLORS 2017 5:14
2025: 1977 2023: 1617 2022: 1475 2021: 1784 2020: 1747 2017: 1318 2016: 1145 Average: 1580
VILLAINS

FEET DON'T FAIL ME

QUEENS OF THE STONE AGE

VILLAINS 2017 5:41
2025: 1349 2024: 1003 2023: 943 2022: 836 2021: 652 2020: 764 2019: 454 2018: 56 Average: 757
24

GOD'S GONNA CUT YOU DOWN

MARILYN MANSON

24 HOURS TO LIVE 2017 2:40
2025: 1312 2024: 1446 2023: 1264 2022: 1061 2021: 642 2020: 186 Average: 985
CROOKED

HELP

PAPA ROACH

CROOKED TEETH 2017 3:34
2025: 1538 2021: 1218 2020: 1022 2019: 1478 2018: 1215 2017: 188 Average: 1110
BLACK

HIGHWAY TUNE

GRETA VAN FLEET

BLACK SMOKE RISING 2017 3:00
2025: 692 2024: 488 2023: 457 2022: 600 2021: 392 2020: 248 2019: 231 2018: 13 Average: 390
HOW

LIGHTS OUT

ROYAL BLOOD

HOW DID WE GET SO DARK? 2017 3:56
2025: 1995 2023: 1872 2022: 1801 2021: 1164 2020: 1176 2019: 984 2018: 634 2017: 116 Average: 1218
PROPHETS

LIVIN' ON THE 110

PROPHETS OF RAGE

PROPHETS OF RAGE 2017 3:48
2025: 1129 2024: 820 2023: 550 2022: 1958 2021: 1527 2020: 1525 2019: 834 2018: 201 Average: 1068
MOTEL

MOTEL POOL

RACING

MOTEL POOL 2017 5:09
2025: 1183 2024: 840 2023: 936 2022: 760 2021: 923 2020: 676 2019: 929 2018: 1122 Average: 921
CONCRETE

RUN

FOO FIGHTERS

CONCRETE AND GOLD 2017 5:23
2025: 1000 2024: 553 2023: 471 2022: 333 2021: 483 2020: 235 2019: 77 2018: 101 2017: 33 Average: 365
WONDERFUL

RUN FOR COVER

THE KILLERS

WONDERFUL WONDERFUL 2017 3:42
2025: 1417 2024: 1309 2023: 1209 2022: 1849 2021: 1668 2020: 1240 2019: 712 2018: 977 Average: 1298
BLACK

SAFARI SONG

GRETA VAN FLEET

BLACK SMOKE RISING 2017 3:54
2025: 1141 2024: 788 2023: 797 2022: 1088 2021: 1228 2020: 662 2019: 747 2018: 174 Average: 828
GET

SMOKO

THE CHATS

GET THIS IN YA!! 2017 2:59
2025: 869 2024: 786 2023: 1531 2022: 1368 2021: 1244 2020: 1521 Average: 1220
HYDROGRAD

SONG #3

STONE SOUR

HYDROGRAD 2017 4:16
2025: 1157 2024: 1004 2023: 1197 2022: 1539 2021: 999 2020: 614 2019: 623 2018: 828 2017: 609 Average: 952
VILLAINS

THE EVIL HAS LANDED

QUEENS OF THE STONE AGE

VILLAINS 2017 6:30
2025: 1673 2024: 1688 2023: 1385 2022: 1444 2021: 1483 2020: 1049 2019: 998 2018: 685 Average: 1301
CONCRETE

THE SKY IS A NEIGHBORHOOD

FOO FIGHTERS

CONCRETE AND GOLD 2017 4:04
2025: 560 2024: 399 2023: 417 2022: 346 2021: 614 2020: 277 2019: 126 2018: 44 Average: 348
WOLVES

THE VIOLENCE

RISE AGAINST

WOLVES 2017 3:48
2025: 1764 2024: 1802 2023: 1895 2022: 1161 2021: 1087 2019: 946 2018: 1155 2017: 536 Average: 1293
VILLAINS

THE WAY YOU USED TO DO

QUEENS OF THE STONE AGE

VILLAINS 2017 4:34
2025: 923 2024: 935 2023: 844 2022: 997 2021: 1027 2020: 559 2019: 529 2018: 227 2017: 97 Average: 682
PROPHETS

UNFUCK THE WORLD

PROPHETS OF RAGE

PROPHETS OF RAGE 2017 4:10
2025: 1273 2024: 720 2023: 957 2022: 637 2021: 688 2020: 453 2019: 535 2018: 33 2017: 155 Average: 606
BLACK

WHEN THE CURTAIN FALLS

GRETA VAN FLEET

BLACK SMOKE RISING 2017 3:42
2025: 1958 2023: 1799 2022: 1825 2021: 1550 2020: 734 2019: 445 2018: 537 Average: 1264