Here's the 2 songs on KARMA AND EFFECT by SEETHER that appeared in the 2024 countdown:
KARMA

REMEDY

SEETHER

KARMA AND EFFECT 2005 3:27
2024: 526 2023: 482 2022: 606 2021: 562 2020: 432 2019: 1476 2016: 1105 2015: 410 2014: 646 2013: 882 2012: 975 2011: 837 2010: 957 2009: 897 2008: 642 2007: 578 2006: 122 Average: 714
KARMA

THE GIFT

SEETHER

KARMA AND EFFECT 2005 5:34
2024: 813 2022: 1619 2021: 1288 2020: 1341 2018: 1199 2016: 966 2013: 535 2012: 606 2011: 756 2010: 826 2009: 923 2008: 867 2007: 474 Average: 939